Influencer Vetting - Evaluate Creators Before You Commit

Go beyond follower counts. Check health indicators, engagement authenticity, viral potential, and growth trends to vet creators properly before any partnership.

Add to Chrome — Free Learn more

Vetting Checklist

What to look for when evaluating an influencer

A follower count tells you nothing about quality. These are the signals that matter when vetting influencers for brand partnerships - and Untapper surfaces all of them automatically.

❤️

Follower Health

The follow-ratio reveals whether followers are real. A creator following 5K people with 200K followers is healthier than one following 50K with 200K.

📊

Engagement Authenticity

Compare median vs. mean engagement. A large gap suggests viral outliers are inflating the numbers - or worse, engagement may be purchased.

🔥

Viral Potential

Does this creator occasionally break out, or are they consistently average? Viral potential measures how often content exceeds the baseline.

📈

Trend Direction

Is the creator growing, stable, or declining? A declining creator may still have large follower counts but less influence going forward.

🌍

Audience Reach

What percentage of followers actually see the content? Low reach-to-follower ratios suggest the audience is inactive or disengaged.

📝

Notes & Scoring

Untapper lets you add private notes and scores to any creator. Build your own influencer scorecard as you vet creators across your pipeline.

The influencer scorecard that does the work for you

Instead of manually checking each signal, Untapper surfaces them all in a single panel. One look tells you if a creator passes or fails your influencer vetting criteria.

  • Green flags: High ER, healthy follow ratio, growing trend, consistent posting frequency
  • Yellow flags: Moderate ER, flat trend, occasional gaps in posting
  • Red flags: Low ER relative to size, high follow ratio, declining trend, large median-mean gap
Influencer Scorecard
Engagement Rate4.2% ✔
Follow Ratio1:380 ✔
Audience Reach14.2% ✔
Trend↗ Growing ✔
Viral PotentialMedium ✓
Median-Mean Gap1.3x ✔
Passed 5/6 checks - Low risk

Influencer due diligence made simple

Vetting influencers shouldn't require a spreadsheet, a team meeting, and three hours of profile-scrolling. Untapper automates the due diligence process so you can evaluate creators as fast as you can browse.

  • Browse any Instagram or TikTok profile - analytics appear instantly
  • Star promising creators and add notes for your team
  • Compare shortlisted creators side by side
  • Export your vetted list when you're ready to reach out
Creators Vetted47
Passed12
Flagged8
Rejected27
Starred5
Notes Added19

Red flags to watch for when vetting influencers

These warning signs suggest a creator may not deliver value for your campaign. Untapper surfaces most of these automatically, but knowing what to look for makes you a better evaluator.

  • Sudden follower spikes without content changes often indicate purchased followers. Real growth is gradual and correlates with content quality.
  • High follower count but very low engagement (under 0.5% ER for any tier) suggests an audience that is mostly bots or inactive accounts.
  • Follow ratio below 1:10 means the creator follows almost as many people as follow them. This is a classic follow-for-follow pattern that produces a disengaged audience.
  • Comments that are generic or emoji-only (fire emoji, "amazing!", "love this!") can signal engagement pods or purchased comments. Real engagement includes specific, thoughtful responses.
  • Large gap between median and mean engagement (over 3x) means performance is extremely inconsistent. You may be paying for an "average" the creator rarely achieves.
Red Flag Alert
ER0.3%
Follow Ratio1:8
Median-Mean Gap4.2x
Trend↘ Declining
HealthPoor
Failed 5/5 checks - Avoid

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about influencer vetting

How long does it take to vet an influencer with Untapper?

About 2-3 seconds per creator. Visit their Instagram or TikTok profile and Untapper instantly overlays all the health indicators, engagement metrics, and scoring signals you need to make a decision.

Can I save my vetting notes?

Yes. Untapper includes a built-in notes system where you can write private notes on any creator. You can also star favorites and assign custom scores, building your own influencer scorecard as you evaluate candidates.

Does Untapper detect fake followers?

Untapper surfaces the signals that indicate fake or inactive followers, including follow ratio, engagement-to-follower ratio, and the median-mean engagement gap. While no tool can definitively prove followers are fake, these signals are strong indicators that experienced marketers rely on.

Vet creators properly.
Before you commit.

Free influencer vetting tool. Health indicators, engagement scoring, and trend analysis for every creator.

Add to Chrome — Free Back to home